ccording
to a recent analysis of
Essential Science Indicators
data, Developmental Science had the highest percent
increase in total
citations among journals in the field of Psychiatry &
Psychology. The journal’s current record includes 332 papers
cited a total of 1,657 times. Published by Wiley-Blackwell,
Developmental Science is celebrating 10 years in publication
this year. In the interview below, Co-Editors-in-Chief Professor
Mark Johnson and Professor Denis Mareschal talk about the
journal’s history, citation record, and future plans. |
Did you expect
Developmental Science to become highly cited, or is this
surprising to you?
The official mission of Developmental
Science is to "represent the very best of contemporary
scientific developmental psychology and developmental cognitive
neuroscience, both in the presentation of theory and in
reporting new data". When established by its founding editor,
George Butterworth, the aim was to become the leading
international journal for scientific and interdisciplinary
approaches to psychological development. After 10 years we look
back on significant progress toward this aim.
|

“...our aim is to
increasingly focus on the highest quality and
most newsworthy papers related to developmental
psychology.” |
|
Since taking up the editorship (Johnson
in 2000, joined by Mareschal in 2005) we have continued to
encourage breadth of coverage and publish the highest quality
papers in developmental imaging, atypical development,
computational modeling, animal behavioral development, as well
as in cognitive behavioral and social development. Many of the
journal’s papers have had significant press coverage, and have
been well cited or very regularly downloaded from our website.
Thus, while we are very gratified by the success of the journal,
we are not surprised.
How would you account for the increased
citation rate of Developmental Science?
Our citation impact and other Thomson
Scientific measures have consistently improved every year since
the first data were published. Thus, we view the increased
citation rate as part of gradual strengthening of the journal
and its reputation. However, in recent years submissions to the
journal have dramatically increased as its reputation has
approached that of the more established journals in
developmental psychology. Another reason for the increased
citation rate may be that the journal is truly international,
with approximately equal submissions and board members from
Europe and North America, in addition to Japan, Australia, and
China.
Was there a change in policy or
editorial direction that might account for this?
In 2001 we established a "fast track"
channel to expediate the processing and publication of papers of
exceptional interest, and this, along with a general policy of
making decisions without multiple rounds of peer-review, may
have partly contributed. We have also published invited special
papers, sections, and issues on cutting-edge topics, some of
which have attracted considerable interest. Finally, we have
catered for work on functional imaging of the developing human
brain by readily publishing the color figures necessary for this
work.
What historical factors have contributed
to the success of Developmental Science?
In contrast to the competitor journals
in our field, Developmental Science is not affiliated
with, or owned by, any scientific society or association. While
this has risks from our publisher’s perspective, it allows the
editors and board to respond rapidly to new and emerging
developments within our field, and to introduce new formats and
procedures without any institutional inertia. We believe that
the journal has established a strong family of loyal readers and
contributors from a variety of different theoretical persuasions
and perspectives. The success of the journal is very largely due
to the support of this scientific family, and we hope it will
continue into the future. The scientific family around the
journal is well illustrated by the contents of our tenth
anniversary special issue published earlier this year: "A decade
of Developmental Science: Issues, themes, and prospects."
Finally, we should also credit our publisher, Wiley-Blackwell,
who have continuously promoted and supported the journal since
its inception.
Have there been specific developments in
the fields served by Developmental Science that may have
contributed?
A new sub-field called developmental
cognitive neuroscience has emerged at the interface of human
cognitive neuroscience and developmental psychology. This
interdisciplinary field attempts to integrate information from
and about the developing brain, with changes in behavioral and
cognitive abilities in infancy and childhood. While several
adult cognitive neuroscience and human development journals
include this new discipline within their remit, Developmental
Science is the only journal that has this new
interdisciplinary field as its primary focus.
What, in your view, is this journal’s
main significance or contribution in the field of Psychiatry &
Psychology?
In our view, Developmental Science
differs markedly from several of the long established journals
in developmental psychology in several ways. First, we actively
encourage papers at the disciplinary borders of developmental
psychology with neuropsychology, artificial intelligence,
functional brain imaging, comparative psychology, and clinical
developmental disorders. Second, we put a higher value on
novelty, and therefore often persevere with papers containing
new methods and ideas that are generally more open to criticism
at the hands of critical reviewers. Third, we weight
computational and theoretical arguments more highly than rival
journals, and will even reject solid empirical papers where they
lack clarity of argument or motivating hypotheses.
How do you see your field(s) evolving in
the next few years?
Developmental psychology is at a
cross-roads. One branch of the field seeks to increasingly make
use of the powerful new empirical and theoretical tools for
understanding how brain functions and genetics relate to
emerging behavioral abilities. This is the branch that
Developmental Science will cater to.
What role do you see for your journal?
We believe that Developmental Science
can achieve the aims of its founding editor and become the
leading broad-scope journal in the field. We have already
planned to implement triage mechanisms for ensuring that we
conduct in-depth review only of papers likely to be of
widespread and significant impact in developmental science.
Thus, our aim is to increasingly focus on the highest quality
and most newsworthy papers related to developmental psychology.
Developmental Science
Professor Mark Johnson and Professor Denis Mareschal,
Editors-in-Chief
Wiley-Blackwell Publishing, publishers
| Developmental Science's
most-cited paper with 13 cites to date: |
|
Durston S,
et al., "A shift from diffuse to focal cortical activity
with development," Dev. Sci. 9(1): 1-8, January 2006. Source:
Essential Science Indicators |
|
|